Jerry Beck's The 50 Greatest Cartoons's comments

Order by:

Add your comment

Do you want to let us know what you think? Just login, after which you will be redirected back here and you can leave your comments.

Comments 1 - 15 of 30

Pickman's avatar

Pickman

What a lame list. It's a shame it virtually doesn't include European or Russian or Japanese animation, you name it. Is "The Cat Came Back" really better than "The Hedgehog in the Fog"? Does "Rabbit of Seville" with its violence-filled slapstick surpass Zbigniew Rybczynski's "Tango" or Raoul Servais' "Siren"? If you look for a definitive list of world's animation, you'd better try Beltessassar's collection.
14 years 1 month ago
BillieDove's avatar

BillieDove

But would you really call "Hedgehog in the fog" a cartoon? This list is fine for what it is.
14 years 1 month ago
Pickman's avatar

Pickman

2 BillieDove: Right, there's some truth in your words. But "L'homme qui plantait des arbres" isn't a cartoon either...
14 years 1 month ago
MrCarmady's avatar

MrCarmady

I love some of these, but it's too skewed towards American animation.
14 years ago
DynatiaCydonia's avatar

DynatiaCydonia

Finally checked them all, gotta say that some do not deserve to appear in this list, like the betty boop ones for example, they are kind of creepy
13 years 11 months ago
MrCarmady's avatar

MrCarmady

The Betty Boop ones are amazing, it's the Clampett stuff that the list is overloaded with. No Russian animation at all is just a crime.
13 years 10 months ago
Cundurs's avatar

Cundurs

Only few I really enjoyed.
13 years 8 months ago
Jumping Elephant's avatar

Jumping Elephant

I was surprised to see that 286 users have platinum awards for this list.
13 years 7 months ago
SilverB33's avatar

SilverB33

I'm not too surprised Jumping Elephant, a lot of these are easily found on Youtube.
13 years 6 months ago
Imps's avatar

Imps

Easiest list to finish on the whole site.

1) The list is never changing, unlike the shorts list
2) Links to every movie are easily available online, and even featured on this site
3) All are like 7 minutes long or so
4) Most of them are easy-viewing
13 years 5 months ago
erndos's avatar

erndos

@Imps thanks for the tip :=)
13 years 4 months ago
JosteinAsk's avatar

JosteinAsk

no Tom & Jerry ?
13 years 3 months ago
Razzomega's avatar

Razzomega

The Cat Concerto is Tom and Jerry ;)!
13 years 3 months ago
chloecat's avatar

chloecat

@ Imps - some of these are featured on this site? Where? I've never seen a section like that!! Thanks :)
13 years 2 months ago
ignatzkat's avatar

ignatzkat

@ chloecat - it's the links that are featured on this site, not the films themselves. Check the comments on a film's page, and there's a chance (a very good chance for stuff on this list) that someone's posted a link to a site where you can watch it.
13 years 1 month ago

Showing items 1 – 15 of 30

View comments