Anatomy of a Murder (1959)'s comments

Do you want to let us know what you think? Just login, after which you will be redirected back here and you can leave your comments.

DynatiaCydonia

If lawyers were all as charismatic as James Stewart, movies would become pointless, people would just have to go to the court. Fascinating film, by the way.

13 years 9 months ago

chaqudemus

James Stewart VS George C. Scott, What's not to love?

12 years 6 months ago

Anatomy of a Murder is an iconic courtroom drama - the poster inspired the Fiasco game's graphic design and Alan Moore's Anatomy Lesson in Swamp Thing, but for most people, it's Jimmy Stewart playing that simple country lawyer - that manages both a dissection of its characters and the event surrounding a murder AND ambiguity as to the verdict's validity. This it does by sticking to Stewart, and not confirming things he's not privy to. In 1959, this naturally shocked audiences, but while we're more used to frank sexual themes and the idea of rape, the film (which is based on a real case) still offers a treatment that is relevant today. Right-minded (that is to say, correct-minded) people know there's never a justification for rape, and yet, trials both legal and public still today re-violate the victim by calling out behavior and dress. I did not feel the tactics used in the film were any different than those used today, which is what remains upsetting today. Of course, how it relates to the murder case is tangential, and almost becomes a distraction. I was retrying it in my head, which the length and procedural pace certainly allow you to do (without ever feeling bored however). Good performances all around, with Stewart and the amusing judge played by Joseph N. Welch (a high profile lawyer, but not an actor, and yet) are the highlights. Lee Remick is properly enigmatic. George C. Scott is a slick shark as the prosecuting attorney, but perhaps a bit too overtly villainous. Jazz fans should check out the Duke Ellington score (and cameo), which supports Stewart's character flying by the seat of his pants during the entire case.

5 years 9 months ago

Shrine_4_cinephiles

Stellar performances by James Stewart(his persuasion in court though kinda was reminiscent of his own Mr.Smith Goes To Washington.) and George C.Scott. Arguments posed in the court-room was very tactfully presented.Clearly stands out as one of the best court-room dramas ever.

10 years 6 months ago

AndrewB

quote:
You want a beer for the dog?
Mm-hmm...He'll go to sleep now.

5 years 7 months ago

deckard

One of the best court dramas out there, really worth watching !

11 years 4 months ago

Buksemannen

Maybe Stewarts best film, he should really have won the academy award for best actor in 1960 instead of Charlton Heston.

13 years 3 months ago

bodoni

Probably the finest trial movie ever made.

The original poster by Saul Bass is a classic of Graphic Design, I don't get why Columbia came with that boring DVD front cover.

13 years 7 months ago

heat_

Although the ending could be classified as dull the movie in general, especially characters and storytelling is so good.

2 years 9 months ago

jo027

Amazing cynical film!

3 years ago

greenhorg

Decent movie, but at no point did I find the defense's case even the least bit convincing.

Maybe that was intentional. It seems like the final scene was poetic justice for freeing a criminal.

10 years 11 months ago