Germania anno zero (1948)
Pssst, want to check out Germania anno zero in our new look?
- Germany Year Zero
- 78 min.
- Rating *
- Votes *
* View IMDb information
See all comments
Aneic - What an absolutely nonsensical "theory"! You would have it that those who depict the "irredeemables" and/or those left behind in the backwash and squalor of society (as with characters in everything from this to "Raging Bull" to "Lilya 4ever" to "Bicycle Thieves") would "soften" their portrayal so we would have it easier. Never mind that there's nothing to support that the filmmakers are "intoxicated with the misery" - you just don't want film to expose you to these things that you would rather ignore. You then project your own inadequacies onto the artist ("I don't like it, so they must be getting some sadistic pleasure out of it!")
Fortunately, there are people more courageous than you, ones who are willing to take us to places and show us people (people who do, in fact, exist) with little hope - people who are living lives of (often) quiet desperation.
These filmmakers (and other individuals who depict those otherwise ignored by society) are doing an essential service for society, and are forcing us to stare into an abyss that we can't afford to ignore. In the process, they also offer the tiniest bit of hope - by depicting such lives with compassion and empathy they ask us to look within ourselves, and to help minimize such suffering in the future, as best we can.
In short: Rossellini was a filmmaker of extraordinary compassion and empathy - the fact that you think that he was somehow "getting off" on the misery being depicted says a lot more about you than it does about the artist.
Italian Neorealist Jojo Rabbit?
Finally, those who would reject those artists of "realist" art are denying some of the best of what film, art, and human expression in general can offer to the world. For it is in such art that some of the greatest expressions of compassion and understanding of the human condition are to be found. Such art is one of the highest forms of human expression, for it reminds us of mankind's duty to help those in need. In the best cases (as with this film), it shakes us out of our apathy, it forces us to confront what we would otherwise choose to ignore.
No, simply watching a film does not fix the world - but it can lead to great things, for the feelings that it instills in you can, and have (in my case, and in the case of others I know) inspire us to create change, to help those around us. They (without glorifying or reveling in poverty or violence or other evils) show us the very human nature of those who have been shut out by society.
Those like aneic would like to deny art's ability to affect people, and to create hope (not the artificial, false hope of a "Slumdog Millionaire" or "Life Is Beautiful," but a more lasting and real hope of a brighter future) - by shining a light in some of the darkest places of our society, they help guide us toward something better.
Sorry for the essay, but the sentiments expressed in aneic's post are incredibly misguided, and I felt the need to correct them.
to see which of your friends have seen this movie!
In 11 official lists
View all lists this movie is in
This movie ranks #3 in Locarno Film Festival - Golden Leopard
This movie ranks #16 in FilmTV's The Best Italian Films
This movie ranks #48 in IMDb's 1940s Top 50
This movie ranks #78 in Kinemathekverbund's The 100 Most Important German Films
This movie ranks #95 in Roy Menarini's Il Grande Cinema Italiano
This movie ranks #191 in Sight & Sound's The Greatest Films of All Time
This movie ranks #240 in TSPDT's 1,000 Greatest Films
This movie ranks #260 in Jonathan Rosenbaum's Essential Cinema
This movie ranks #318 in The New York Times's Book of Movies
This movie ranks #363 in David Thomson's Have You Seen?
This movie ranks #556 in The Criterion Collection