Order by:

Add your comment

Do you want to let us know what you think? Just login, after which you will be redirected back here and you can leave your comments.

Comments 1 - 15 of 18

marco_n65's avatar

marco_n65

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viyufRQKlto
7 years 7 months ago
ChrisReynolds's avatar

ChrisReynolds

Given that the video is created from the actual original footage that provided the visuals of the short, combined with the music that provided the soundtrack to the short, and is, as the description says "give or take a few frames here and there, it is nearly identical to the actual video", I see no problem with saying that that video IS the "God is Dog Spelled Backwards" short. A lot of remastering and restoration work has to do something very similar when the best available surviving visuals and soundtrack are on different copies and need to be combined.
11 years 8 months ago
samoan's avatar

samoan

As art short films go, this one was actually pretty cool seeing all that art in such a small time. Makes you not want to blink, plus nice music to accompany it.
7 years 2 months ago
marienbad's avatar

marienbad

Hmm, I wonder how much 40 years distorted his memory of the film. I assume it is close enough for a check... Especially since it sounds like it will be impossible for anyone to ever see the original anyway. I'll hold off on checking it though.
11 years 12 months ago
Dimitris Psachos Springer's avatar

Dimitris Psachos Springer

Local is correct and whoever has checked it should immediately uncheck it but I presume anyone has the right to do what they wish to, I for myself will follow my conscience and as with many unsubtitled films, I'll wait for the original copy to surface somewhere...unless of course a link DOES exist somewhere and I haven't noticed.
12 years ago
Local Hero -- aka MestnyiGeroi's avatar

Local Hero -- aka MestnyiGeroi

I'm no expert on this film whatsoever, but it doesn't seem to me that that link should count as a viewing of the original film. It's a re-make/re-vamp.
12 years ago
cobweb's avatar

cobweb

Some additional background by Mason Williams:
https://www.classicalgas.com/gasvideo.html

The segment from The Summer Brothers Smothers Show is not lost to everyone so it may appear online one day.
2 months 4 weeks ago
xianjiro's avatar

xianjiro

Wow. So much human endeavor distilled down into three-minutes of utter beauty made me want to cry. It was inspiring if heavily weighted in favor of European arts (though I did see some East Asian, mainly Japanese, paintings as well as proto-European art). But I still give it a beautiful thumbs up!

Edit: Just not a check. Okay, I went back and reread the Vimeo description much more closely and no longer believe this to be the same movie. The implication is it does still exist but copyright issues block its release. Additionally, the original was to Beethoven's Fifth Symphony so I'd say the Vimeo link is to a different film - not different enough though that the powers that be have blocked it in the US (unless you have a work around).

Hmmm, define original - which version of Blade Runner earns a check? I've seen them all - should I get multiple checks? NO? Well I think IMDb (which our database works off of) should include each and every one and list authors should be required to specifiy. While I can't think of names off the top of my head, I know a number of Criterion Collection and other arthouse DVDs are restorations of films that may include sections cobbled together from here and there. I've seen at least one, that in an attempt to return the film to it's "original state", included still photos along with the existing sound track for footage that was destroyed after being edited to please someone. Maybe we should disallow any viewing online, on DVD, on VHS, etc unless that is the original media the film was created in as well. Can anyone spell pedantic? (Besides me?)

EDIT 20161009: someone kindly shared the original with me - check earned ;)
8 years 11 months ago
Armoreska's avatar

Armoreska

The original version is on KG
10 years 2 months ago
Camille Deadpan's avatar

Camille Deadpan

I didn't blink at all. :D
10 years 4 months ago
Armoreska's avatar

Armoreska

Did you pause to blink?
10 years 9 months ago
Torgo's avatar

Torgo

Anyway, even if it doesn't .. I am now cultured.
11 years ago
Lux-Lucis's avatar

Lux-Lucis

The link doesn't count, if you're honest.
11 years 5 months ago
John Milton's avatar

John Milton

I'll hold of too, but kinda feel like checking it...
11 years 6 months ago
anne_f_'s avatar

anne_f_

I checked it and then unchecked. I'd feel happier about checking it for the Classical Gas Video as although created from the original student video (i.e. God is Dog Spelled Backwards) it is "nearly identical to the actual video that aired on the Smothers Brothers Comedy Hour in 1968" (i.e. the Classical Gas Video).
All that said, the vimeo video is well worth watching even if you can't check it off on ICM afterwards :-)
11 years 6 months ago

Showing items 1 – 15 of 18

View comments