10 Almost-Great Screenplays

10 Almost-Great Screenplays's icon

Created by Igor_Brynner.

Favorited 1 time, disliked 0 times, added to 0 watchlists.

An almost-great screenplay can be more frustrating than a really bad one. The potential is strong and the execution is almost there, but something went wrong at the final hurdle.

Of course, it’s easy to pick out flaws in retrospect or to credit (or blame) the writer for something that wasn’t their idea. So many things can go wrong on a script’s journey to the screen that it can feel like a miracle there are any almost-great films in the first place.

The problem is, as author and screenwriter William Goldman famously said:

“Nobody knows anything…… Not one person in the entire motion picture field knows for a certainty what’s going to work. Every time out it’s a guess and, if you’re lucky, an educated one.”

With all that in mind, and judging from what made it into the finished films, for this list we focus on 10 almost-great screenplays, what flaws each script has and how, with a few tweaks, they could have been great.

Remove ads

Filter

  1. 1 new

    Prometheus

    2012, in 4 top lists Check
  2. 2 new

    No Country for Old Men

    2007, in 23 top lists Check
  3. 3 new

    Chasing Amy

    1997, in 2 top lists Check
  4. 4 new

    Eyes Wide Shut

    1999, in 11 top lists Check
  5. 5 new

    Stripes

    1981, in 3 top lists Check
  6. 6 new

    Fallen

    1998, in 0 top lists Check
  7. 7 new

    Punch-Drunk Love

    2002, in 12 top lists Check
  8. 8 new

    Real Genius

    1985, in 1 top list Check
  9. 9 new

    Panic Room

    2002, in 2 top lists Check
  10. 10 new

    Collateral

    2004, in 6 top lists Check
Remove ads

Last updated on Apr 20, 2023; source