Making a Murderer (2015)'s comments

Do you want to let us know what you think? Just login, after which you will be redirected back here and you can leave your comments.

peterskb45

Fascinating story, but the pacing was poor. There has to be more interesting way to present the story besides helicopter shots of a junkyard and zooming in on court documents.

8 years 3 months ago

I don't know if Steven Avery commited the crime he's put away for. If not, there's something seriously rotten in the State of Wisconsin. If so, probably too. I don't mind the documentary being biased. Much. I do mind the lack of answers on very basic questions. Is this a problem of Wisconsin or is it a federal issue? Is it impossible to get a new trial? If so, whyyy? Is an appeal basicly always rejected? In other words: try to elevate this thing above the conspiray.

8 years 3 months ago

Adamov10

Harsh, great tv

The Jinx was a little bit better

8 years 3 months ago

Realenur

I am really shocked at the family's very limited intelligence, especially Brandon who with his '' I don't know '' answers to even simple questions are complete incompetent.

On the one hand you have the family which is really easy to hate and on the other hand, you has the worst police force ever seen.

I can't say whether the man is innocent or guilty, but if you have a grudge against him, he seems not as the most difficult to blame.

Steven Avery is no genius, but he does, however have a little more brain than the remainder of the family. I came to think of Edward Norton's character in Primal Fear, Avery can maybe act complete stupid and claiming everyone is after him, but be smarter than we know. - People love such a hero who goes against the system.

If someone knew where the girl was going that day in 2005 and one has to harm her then he could easily take two and two together about who would be blamed for the crime and the killer could throw the evidence directly on the property.

Her brother, her ex-boyfriend, Avery's brother or nephews could be behind the murder.

That the car was found on the property, tucked under a few branches either indicate that the person behind is a complete idiot or want it to be found.

Her brother and ex-boyfriend seemed mysterious about the messages from her mobile which was deleted. Could they have said something to her, they dont want others to hear? the ex-boyfriend may have been jealous of anything and has not progressed the break-up and planned it when he found out where she was going that day. It's the perfect crime.

I'm not saying the police are behind the murder, but they could had tampered with the evidence in order to save their reputation.

I can't understand that we at no time hear Avery talk about his kids and if he misses them or anything. Like he dont care about them. There are several things I cant fit together. If my nephew and I was accused of a crime, even though we were both innocent, I would take full responsibility so he could go free.

The kid said his first statement came from a book. He is totally stupid, he can't possibly read and understand a book. He has seen or participated in something, his brain struggled to cope.

There are several things I have trouble understanding. BUT. Is the man guilty or not, it's still a huge mystery. Several things have came to light after the series ended. Among other things, Avery's ex girlfriend has said that Avery was violent during their relationship and the girl that should take pictures, said that she did not want to visit his property again, so she has obviously not been comfortable with Avery or the family. Avery used a false phone number and ID to get Teresa to his property the day she disappeared. But it makes no sense because he could not give her a false address and she could look up and said no to the job if the did not feel safe about him.

Avery has stated that his brothers could be behind.

It is an interesting documentary series that caught my attention right from the start.

7 years 3 months ago

Limbesdautomne

People here really should watch season 2...

1 year 8 months ago

chryzsh

Well ... fuck

8 years 4 months ago

Nibbler

Amazing!

8 years 3 months ago

der Zorn Gottes

After seeing the absolutely brilliant The Jinx earlier this year, I was hoping that this would live up to the hype, but it sure didn't. I can't and won't believe that the American public and the people who act all shocked about this show are naive enough to think that shit like this doesn't happen everywhere. People trying to elevate their status have been preying on simpleminded and poor individuals since the very beginning of the justice system, so there's nothing new or shocking to the story.

There's also a complete lack of likeable characters in this document. A document like this requires that Bob Durst who keeps the intrigue alive. All this document had to give you was incest ridden hillbillies, who were impossible to relate with, and truly despicable individuals who preyed on their stupidity, and of course a little sprinkle of warriors of justice who couldn't get their thumbs out of their asses. And oh boy was that Brendan kid infuriatingly stupid, but hey, atleast Hollywood will have the easiest day of their lives when casting Paul Dano for his role in the possible movie.

All in all, this document felt like it was just dragging and dragging without any new revelations or points of interests rising up. But I guess if the last thing you watched was five seasons of Modern Family, you'd be AMAZED by this when you came across it on Cancerflix.

7 years 8 months ago