Remove ads

Information

Year
1930
Runtime
136 min.
Director
Lewis Milestone
Genres
Drama, War
Rating *
8.1
Votes *
39,424
Checks
12,564
Favs
686
Dislikes
62
Favs/checks
5.5% (1:18)
Favs/dislikes
11:1
* View IMDb information

Top comments

  1. Timec's avatar

    Timec

    niesl2-

    And what was Shakespeare thinking, giving all his Italian and Danish (and so on) characters poetic English dialogue? Man, very few productions of "Hamlet" even have the actors speaking with a Danish accent.

    But seriously - that's not a flaw. In fact, considering that the movie was made for an American audience, it was actually a very smart move to have them talk in English and without accents. Like it or not, foreign languages are a barrier to understanding and empathy for many people, and a decision to shoot this in German would have made the film less powerful than it is. By speaking English, audiences who might reject subtitled films were forced to empathize with a group that had been their enemy less than fifteen years earlier - by giving the characters everyday English dialogue it gave the impression that these people were, indeed, quite human, and that, in most cases, they weren't all that different than the average American in the audience. They had the same concerns, the same fears, the same hopes...

    It does get more tricky when different characters would, in reality, be speaking different languages (that is to say, if we had an English soldier and a German soldier among the main characters) - but since that's not the case here, it's entirely reasonable that the characters speak English, as we the audience are given insight, are made witness of a world and experience that we may otherwise never have known.

    In other words, having foreign characters speaking something other than their native language is an entirely acceptable stylistic device, one that had been established for a long, long time before film even came around. That device is used to brilliant effect here.

    So a dogmatic "Oh no, they're speaking something other than their native language and that ruins the film" approach is entirely wrongheaded, and will lead you to reject some of the greatest films of all time (as well as some of the greatest works of theater, opera, and literature.) Those looking for that sort of verisimilitude are going to want to turn to something other than film, or literature, or theater, or pretty much any art form that contains the spoken word.
    7 years 3 months ago
  2. Fluegi's avatar

    Fluegi

    The mother of all anti-war movies and probably one of the best. Very intensive. 4 years ago
  3. Camille Deadpan's avatar

    Camille Deadpan

    This movie reminded me of what Stefan Zweig mentioned about WWI in his Die Welt von Gestern (1942). The movie is so sad and shocking and realistic and so amazing. Also it left me speechless. 4 years 10 months ago
See all comments

Friends

Login to see which of your friends have seen this movie!

Activity

  1. square1josh checked this movie 2 hours 33 minutes ago
  2. Jfkskdmh checked this movie 6 hours 49 minutes ago
  3. Kyraa87 and elshambillo checked this movie 3 days 9 hours ago
  4. Blearwargh added this movie to their watchlist 4 days 15 hours ago
See more activity

In 17 official lists

  1. This movie ranks #4 in Tim Dirks' Most Controversial Films of All-Time
    Tim Dirks' Most Controversial Films of All-Time's icon

    Tim Dirks' Most Controve…

    4
  2. This movie ranks #4 in Academy Award Best Pictures
    Academy Award Best Pictures's icon

    Academy Award Best Pictu…

    4
  3. This movie ranks #7 in 101 War Movies You Must See Before You Die
    101 War Movies You Must See Before You Die's icon

    101 War Movies You Must …

    7
  4. This movie ranks #10 in 1930s
    1930s's icon

    1930s

    10
  5. This movie ranks #12 in Academy Award Best Picture Nominees
    Academy Award Best Picture Nominees's icon

    Academy Award Best Pictu…

    12
  6. This movie ranks #13 in 100 Must-See Films Of The 20th Century
    100 Must-See Films Of The 20th Century's icon

    100 Must-See Films Of Th…

    13
  7. This movie ranks #22 in The Best 1,000 Movies Ever Made
    The Best 1,000 Movies Ever Made's icon

    The Best 1,000 Movies Ev…

    22
  8. This movie ranks #28 in National Film Registry
    National Film Registry's icon

    National Film Registry

    28
  9. This movie ranks #36 in War
    War's icon

    War

    36
  10. This movie ranks #50 in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die
    1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die's icon

    1001 Movies You Must See…

    50
  11. This movie ranks #51 in Best Of Rotten Tomatoes
    Best Of Rotten Tomatoes's icon

    Best Of Rotten Tomatoes

    51
  12. This movie ranks #71 in The British Film Institute: 360 Classics
    The British Film Institute: 360 Classics's icon

    The British Film Institu…

    71
  13. This movie ranks #83 in Have You Seen? A Personal Introduction to 1,000 Films
    Have You Seen? A Personal Introduction to 1,000 Films's icon

    Have You Seen? A Persona…

    83
  14. This movie ranks #101 in Halliwell's Top 1000: The Ultimate Movie Countdown
    Halliwell's Top 1000: The Ultimate Movie Countdown's icon

    Halliwell's Top 1000: Th…

    101
  15. This movie ranks #101 in Jonathan Rosenbaum's Essential Films
    Jonathan Rosenbaum's Essential Films's icon

    Jonathan Rosenbaum's Ess…

    101
  16. This movie ranks #402 in 501 Must See Movies
    501 Must See Movies's icon

    501 Must See Movies

    402
  17. This movie ranks #737 in They Shoot Pictures, Don't They?
    They Shoot Pictures, Don't They?'s icon

    They Shoot Pictures, Don…

    737
View all lists this movie is in