Order by:

Add your comment

Do you want to let us know what you think? Just login, after which you will be redirected back here and you can leave your comments.

Comments 1 - 9 of 9

Unit 731's avatar

Unit 731

天皇陛下!バンザイ!

A great man was once asked "What can change the nature of a man?". Now, that may
seem overly ambitious for a mere feature to explore such a question, but the central question of this
behemoth of a film might as well be "What is the nature of a man?".

Few movies actually feel like a fucking journey, and I have to say that this one was the best joruney
I have ever experienced on film. 10 hour run time, Tatsuya Nakadai, 1940's Manchuria. It certainly had my interest, and after watching a great deal of Japanese cinema, I decided to pearl-harbor this bad boy, a film that some of the even most enlightened "critics" avoid.
I knew this movie was going to push all the philosophical buttons, but never in my wildest dreams did I expect it to be this bleak and full of despair.

It is magnificent. Almost every scene is full of thought and subtext, and the movie pumps out more thought-provoking dialogue than Spike Lee pumps out bad movies.
It raises a lot of great questions on the titular human condition. What is one's place in the world? Are people victims of their surroudnings? Is the road to hell paved with good intentions? How much can a man endure? And the list goes on. Yet it never feels pretentious because the things portrayed are true to the historical setting and the protagonist.
And all this delicious dialogue and exposition is matched with really beautiful scenery and outstanding camera-work.

This piece can feel a little exhausting at times, I too did feel it at one point, but I was always interested to see what happened next to the protagonist of the journey, Kaji. Now Kaji is an interesting fellow. A japanese pacifist who always sees the good in people and expects the best from them. He is ridiculously idealistic and his character presents us with many wonderful dilemmas and discussions on life and all things it encompasses.
The character arc has to be the best I've seen and Tatsuya Nakadai delivers absolutely groundbreaking role. For me, to grow attached to a character is very rare and it's amazing how I hoped the best for Kaji, despite some of the stupid decisions he made.
The only thing that bothered me slightly was the portrayal of his relationship to his wife, while it was always a very small part of the big picture, but the cheesy soundtrack on the background on some scenes felt really off. But it was really great to see Kaji still trying to reach his wife in the third part, even though the fate of his wife was laid out in front of him.
In conclusion, Kaji has to be the most fully realised character in the history of cinema.

I don't think the movie has any real weaknesses. Except the absolutely ridiculous PPSH's the russians carry. WTF? Lend-leased Shermans I can deal with, but this?

As I said, it can feel a bit exhausting but like good stories, it rewards you if you are patient and give it time. I think more directors should have the balls to do something as long and grand as this, and give a subject matter the scope it deserves. I had to sleep on this for a while before writing something about it because in my opinion this movie really gets better once you have reflected on it. Out of all the great scenes this film has to offer, from the exectuion scene to the "trial" scene, the ending still has to be the most powerful. It is one of the best endings
ever and absolutely impressive. The ending is a testament to the futility of everything, and only after the ending I got the whole picture of humanity Kobayashi tries to tell us about. Isn't it just wonderful how beliefs and ideologies crumble under extraordinary circumstances?

While trilogies like LOTR are probably better in terms of pure entertainment, I think I found my favorite trilógie. It is everything I ever wanted from such a colossal undertaking and then some. Without a doubt one of the greatest journeys of our time.

Right?
image

quote:
It can't be helped....
5 years 5 months ago
Torgo's avatar

Torgo

Those last 15 minutes after a bleakest 9-1/2-hour-vision of war may belong to the most devastating moments in the history of cinema.

Monumental.
7 years 10 months ago
Dieguito's avatar

Dieguito

Brilliant ending for the trilogy, maybe the best of all! This whole trilogy seems to be a treasure still to be discovered.. Even by specialized critics!
7 years 11 months ago
george4mon's avatar

george4mon

i was put off watching these films because of their long run time, but the whole trilogy was superb! watch it!
7 years ago
TheMajor's avatar

TheMajor

One of the best movie endings.
8 years 9 months ago
tomwtm's avatar

tomwtm

managed to pick up the whole trilogy from the BFI Southbank :D
7 years ago
Local Hero -- aka MestnyiGeroi's avatar

Local Hero -- aka MestnyiGeroi

@ amishera: I rented the trilogy from Netflix. Try again.
7 years 2 months ago
LuckeWent's avatar

LuckeWent

Kaji is the man!
7 years 11 months ago
amishera's avatar

amishera

Anyone knows where I can rent this movie from? Netflix apparently doesn't have this.
7 years 11 months ago
View comments