Pssst, want to check out Shane in our new look?
See all comments
The kid's voice will haunt me for years. Like watching a cardboard cutout squeal for two full hours.
Shane: "A gun is a tool, Marian; no better or no worse than any other tool: an axe, a shovel or anything. A gun is as good or as bad as the man using it. Remember that."
...aaaand everyone in the NRA just came in their pants.
dickwinters: so "Shane looked like a gay", therefore he's not a viable heroic character? Because gay men can't possibly be gunfighters or cowboys, can they? You certainly live up to your name "dick", you idiot.
Anyway, dick aside, it's a strange western- terribly sentimental and simplistic, especially next to the complex and fascinating characters of a Ford or Mann western. Ladd is quite wooden in the underwritten title role, particularly contrasted to Van Heflin's spiky landowner and Jack Palance's sneering, amoral gunslinger. It all goes wrong with Joey though, one of the most annoying kids ever put on screen... just one more "aaaaawwww Shaaaaaane" and I might throw up... Brandon de Wilde made up for it ten years later with a decent showing in "Hud", but this is just horrible. Some of the dialogue is unintentionally funny as well - the relationship between Shane and Joey reaches a great climax when Shane tells him to "grow up straight". Some chance.
In the positive the scenery is beautiful, although completely over saturated, the assorted showdowns are well paced, there's a couple of great movie dogs, and the bar fight is impressively brutal for an otherwise dramatically limp and obvious story. Not the classic I expected.
to see which of your friends have seen this movie!
In 18 official lists
View all lists this movie is in
This movie ranks #44 in Academy Award - Best Cinematography
This movie ranks #45 in AFI's 100 Years...100 Movies
This movie ranks #45 in IMDb's Western Top 50
This movie ranks #53 in AFI's 100 Years...100 Cheers
This movie ranks #78 in BFI's 100 Westerns
This movie ranks #113 in Roger Ebert's Great Movies
This movie ranks #115 in Library of Congress's National Film Registry
This movie ranks #193 in Academy Award - Best Picture Nominees
This movie ranks #227 in BFI's 360 Classic Feature Films Project
This movie ranks #241 in Eureka!'s The Masters of Cinema Series
This movie ranks #255 in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die
This movie ranks #415 in Halliwell's Top 1000: The Ultimate Movie Countdown
This movie ranks #465 in Emma Beare's 501 Must-See Movies
This movie ranks #466 in TSPDT's 1,000 Greatest Films
This movie ranks #467 in David Thomson's Have You Seen?
This movie ranks #775 in The New York Times's Book of Movies
This movie ranks #792 in Sight & Sound's The Greatest Films of All Time
This movie ranks #798 in The Guardian's 1000 Films to See Before You Die